Which One : 17th century Cornwall.
Cast : The Doctor : William Hartnell
Polly : Anneke Wills
Ben Jackson : Michael Craze
Jacob Kewper : David Blake Kelly
Joseph Longfoot : Terence De Marney
Cherub : George A. Cooper
Josiah Blake : John Ringham
Captain Pike : Michael Godfrey
Tom : Mike Lucas
The Squire : Paul Whitsun-Jones
Spaniard : Derek Ware
Jamaica : Elroy Josephs
Gaptooth : Jack Bligh
Written By : Bryan Hayles
Produced By : Innes Lloyd
First UK Broadcast : 10 September – 1 October 1966.
Length : 4 x 25 minute parts.
Plot : The Tardis land in 17th century Cornwall amd the Doctor, Ben and Polly encounter a vicious group of Smugglers.
Whats good : An interesting period setting. Nice on-location scenery. Some supporting characters are well played.
Whats bad : It’s a bit dull. Never really builds to anything substanial. Could have been shorter.
Review With Spoilers : The Smugglers is the first episode of season 4 and features a period episode set in 17th century Cornwall.
The Tardis lands on a beach and Doctor, Ben and Polly land travel to a local Church; where a frightened Church Warder imparts a secret on the Doctor – about some hidden treasure.
Later on, the Warder is killed by a group of Smugglers, who learn of the Doctor’s new found secret and kidnap him; in an attempt to learn where the treasure is buried.
The Smugglers follows hot-on-heels of a number of previous Hartnell period-dramas – all of varying quality. One thing that The Smugglers does have going for it – is the unique 17th century Cornish setting; the time of the fearsome Smugglers.
Coupled with some nice on-location shooting of real Cornwall locations, gives The Smugglers – a unique period feel.
“If you should come this way again and find me gone, remember these words. This is Deadman’s secret key: Smallwood, Ringwood, Gurney! It’s a secret worth remembering…!”Joseph Longfoot
The Smugglers also sports a couple of memorable performances, from George A. Cooper – as the fearsome Smuggler assassin Cherub and Michael Godfrey – as Captain Pike.
Ben and Polly also provide some usefully interspersed light-hearted moments. Especially, the running gag of Polly being mistaken for a boy; as she wears trousers and Ben being told to shut-up all the time; due to being percieved as a young squire to the Doctor.
On the whole though, The Smugglers feels like an un-necessary harkback to the earlier bland talky period Who’s. Where little happens except a lot of talking.
This is despite a number of other much better prriod dramas, which have a nice blend of action, drama and talking, including; The Crusade and The Gunfighters – for example. Additionally, viewing figures for The Smugglers, were the lowest – of any Hartnell adventure.
It was also the episode, where it finally become apparent that William Hartnell’s health had deteriorated to the point where he was able to continue playing the role of the Doctor. Therefore, the decision was made to recast – after the following serial; The Tenth Planet.
The Smugglers can best be summed up, as an authentic looking but ultimately insipid smuggling yarn; that could have benefited from a Sci-Fi angle – to give it a bit of interest. Sadly, it was just another straight-up period romp with little memorability.