The Real (Sylvester) McCoy – A Seasonal Introduction
Old Doctor Who

Old Doctor Who attempts to chronicle every episode of Doctor Who is finally bearing fruit.

Apart from a scattering of reviews on each Doctors review page. We have now completed all of the Seventh Doctor – Sylvester McCoy’s run as the Timelord.

McCoy’s Who felt, at least renewed of purpose somewhat after the personnel changes behind the scenes. McCoy’s era can at least be commended, for re-focusing the show; after the wayward Baker years.

Featuring a mixed bag of downright terrible and instant classics. Season’s 24, 25 & 26 – are perhaps among the most varied, in tone.


Instant classics, such as The Curse of Fenric – 1989, Silver Nemesis – 1988 and Remembrance of the Daleks – 1988 and The Greatest Show In the Galaxy – 1988. Were interspersed with absolute howlers such as; The Happiness Patrol – 1988, Paradise Towers – 1987, Ghost Light – 1989 and Delta And the Bannermen – 1987 .

McCoy’s reign got off to a problematic start with Time And the Rani – 1987 as the episode was penned before his appointment. The final result, although guilty of not showcasing the new Doctor – was averagedly-reasonable in its self; thanks to spirited reprise – by the Rani..


Talking of averagedly-reasonable, Dragonfire – 1987 and Battlefield – 1989 held the middle ground, as promising stories with good ideas; which only really fell down – in the final execution.

Final story, Survival – 1989 shares its own pinnacle of awfulness. Completely unworthy of the monicker of “last original series Who – ever”. It was a low note to go out on, especially after the excellent – The Curse of Fenric – 1989.


McCoy’s era also sported the two extremes of companionship; the annoying twittering Mel and the much more likeable Ace. Ace was given what no other companion to date had been given before – a complete backstory. Intertwined around many of the episodes.

McCoy himself began as a juggling buffoon (in the Troughton mould) but by the begining of showcase season 25 began to withdraw into a much darker, introverted and moody character.

This is probably best summed up, by his cold and calculating destruction of planet Skaro in Remembrance of the Daleks.

Love or hate McCoy’s era, at least it was memorable.

What was your favourite McCoy episode?


You can find out more on each episode below :

Season Twenty-Four – 1987

Time And the Rani🔵🔵🔵⚪⚪
Paradise Towers🔵🔵🔘⚪⚪
Delta And the Bannermen🔵🔵⚪⚪⚪

Season Twenty-Five – 1988

Remembrance of the Daleks⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
The Happiness Patrol🔴⚪⚪⚪⚪
Silver Nemesis⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
The Greatest Show In the Galaxy⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Season Twenty-Six – 1989

Ghost Light🔵🔵🔘⚪⚪
The Curse of Fenric⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Comments are closed.